I understand what you're saying, but ....
I was thinking that I could offer the password to all paid members upon registration, change the password once a year to make them keep their dues up. (This forum would be just one of their benefits.)
Anyway, another surfer would stumble upon the forum, register without reading the rules, curse because they don't have a password, read the rules, not want to become a member, never come back, and their info would be taking up space in my database.
That's what I'm saying.